Attorneys with the Canton-based law firm Plakas Mannos, representing Massillon Washington High School football players Brayton and Brydon Feister, filed an emergency motion Friday morning accusing the Ohio High School Athletic Association of violating a court injunction by suspending the brothers just one day before the Tigers’ highly anticipated playoff matchup against Columbus Watterson.
The nine-page motion, filed with Ohio’s Fifth District Court of Appeals on Nov. 20, asks judges to immediately enforce an Oct. 16 injunction that prohibited OHSAA from preventing the brothers from participating in varsity football for the remainder of the 2026 season.
The filing comes after OHSAA announced Thursday that both players were being suspended for 30 days while the association continues investigating alleged recruiting violations related to their transfer to Massillon earlier this year.
Attorneys Lee E. Plakas, W. Scott Gwin, David L. Dingwell and Gene L. Valentino, of Plakas Mannos, argue that the latest suspensions directly contradict the appellate court’s previous ruling.
“On November 19, at the eleventh hour and on the eve of what has been coined ‘Ohio’s high school football game of the year,’ OHSAA brazenly violated this Court’s order,” attorneys wrote in the motion.
The attorneys contend the suspensions effectively end the brothers’ football season without a hearing or due process.
Attorneys argue OHSAA is circumventing court order
The legal dispute involving the Feister brothers has been ongoing for months, with questions surrounding their eligibility and transfer to Massillon making their way through Ohio’s court system.
On Oct. 16, the Fifth District Court of Appeals issued an injunction preventing OHSAA from restricting either brother’s participation in Massillon varsity football games for the remainder of the season.
OHSAA subsequently challenged the injunction, including through an action before the Ohio Supreme Court.
According to Friday’s filing, the Supreme Court dismissed that action Nov. 5 and denied OHSAA’s emergency request to stay the injunction as moot.
Attorneys argue the injunction remains in effect and that OHSAA acknowledged in an Oct. 23 filing that the order covered every tournament game Massillon would play.
However, on Thursday, OHSAA Executive Director Doug Ute notified Massillon Superintendent Paul Salvino that the association was immediately removing both players’ athletic eligibility for 30 days under Bylaw 4-9-2.
OHSAA characterized the latest suspensions as separate from its previous transfer eligibility determination.
The Feisters’ attorneys dispute that distinction.
According to the motion, OHSAA had already investigated allegations involving the brothers’ father allegedly contacting other schools about enrolling his sons. Attorneys also said the association previously examined the family’s businesses, investments, home purchases and financial affairs.
The filing argues that those allegations were part of the earlier eligibility dispute and cannot be used again under a different bylaw to circumvent the existing injunction.
“OHSAA cannot give the same allegations new force simply by invoking a different bylaw as an excuse for violating a Court Order,” attorneys wrote.
The motion also argues that OHSAA should have sought modification of the existing injunction rather than imposing new suspensions while the court order remained in effect.
Family asks court to consider contempt
In addition to seeking immediate reinstatement, attorneys with Plakas Mannos are asking the appeals court to require OHSAA to explain why its actions should not be considered a violation of the Oct. 16 injunction.
The filing cites Ohio case law establishing that injunctions must be followed unless they are modified or dissolved by a court.
Attorneys argue that courts have the authority to enforce their orders and punish violations through contempt proceedings.
The family is requesting that the court prohibit OHSAA officials, employees, agents and referees from enforcing Thursday’s suspensions or otherwise interfering with the brothers’ participation.
The motion also asks the court to prevent OHSAA from directing or encouraging Massillon City Schools personnel to keep either player off the field.
Attorneys emphasize significance of Friday’s game
The filing highlights the personal significance of Friday night’s playoff game, particularly for Brayton Feister, who is a senior.
Attorneys included a childhood photograph of the brothers wearing football uniforms, emphasizing their years of playing together and the possibility that Friday could be among their final opportunities to compete as teammates.
“Once this game is gone, no court can give these brothers that moment back,” attorneys wrote beneath the photograph.
The motion argues that allowing the suspensions to remain in place while the legal dispute continues would cause irreparable harm because the game cannot be replayed.
Immediate decision requested
The Feister family, through its attorneys at Plakas Mannos, is asking the Fifth District Court of Appeals to issue an immediate ruling before Massillon takes the field against Columbus Watterson on Friday evening.
Specifically, attorneys want the court to enforce its previous injunction, prohibit enforcement of the new suspensions or, alternatively, grant temporary protection allowing the brothers to participate while the court conducts an expedited hearing.
The filing also requests that OHSAA be ordered to show cause why its Nov. 19 suspensions do not violate the court’s existing order.
The emergency motion represents the latest development in a legal battle that has continued throughout Massillon’s football season.
As of the filing, the document does not establish that the appeals court has ruled on the emergency request or that the brothers have been cleared to participate in Friday’s game.



