Louisville renews girls basketball coach’s contract amid allegations

The Louisville community is expressing concern following allegations of inappropriate conduct involving girls’ basketball coach Dan Moody. The allegations, which surfaced last year, have prompted extensive investigations by both the Louisville City School District and external agencies. Despite these claims, the Louisville Board of Education voted to renew Moody’s supplemental contract during a school board meeting last week.

The accusations against Moody initially came to light in November 2023, when two female athletes filed complaints of inappropriate behavior during practice sessions. According to a statement released by the Louisville City School District, the administration immediately launched an investigation that spanned four months and involved interviews with more than 20 individuals, including the athletes, coaching staff, and others associated with the program. The investigation also included a review of hours of video footage.

In a statement from the school district, officials emphasized their commitment to student safety and noted that after an exhaustive review, the findings concluded that Moody had not engaged in inappropriate or unprofessional conduct. Despite the outcome, the athletes were provided alternatives during the investigation to ensure their comfort in participating in the program.

“The District takes seriously its responsibility to create a positive and safe environment for all students and staff,” the statement read. “We understand the impact that unfounded rumors and allegations can have, particularly when spread through social media.”

However, the families of the athletes have pushed back on the district’s handling of the situation. Attorney Caitlyn Benzo, representing the families, criticized the district for what she described as a “self-serving” investigation that failed to properly address the allegations. According to Benzo, the district delayed involving compliance officers and did not act swiftly to protect the athletes.

“Several young student-athletes have bravely spoken up after encountering uncomfortable and distressing situations. The district mishandled these reports from the beginning, ignoring explicit Board policies and failing to ensure the safety of the athletes,” Benzo said in a statement. She added that the families had requested a neutral, third-party investigation, but their request was denied.

Benzo also clarified that the investigations conducted by Louisville Police and Child Protective Services were initiated independently of the families. While no criminal charges were brought, Child Protective Services substantiated claims of emotional maltreatment. That ruling is being appealed by Moody and his attorney.

Moody’s attorney, Andrew Stebbins, responded to the allegations by asserting that some families had opposed Moody’s hiring from the start and had since tried multiple avenues to have him removed, including filing false sex-related allegations. Stebbins emphasized that both the district’s investigation and separate inquiries by police and child services found no evidence of sexual misconduct.

“We have justly denied the allegations from the beginning and stand behind the thorough investigation conducted by the school,” Stebbins said. He noted that the coaching staff, which collectively has 68 years of experience, remains committed to the well-being of the students.

The Louisville Board of Education voted to renew Moody’s contract despite these ongoing concerns. In their statement, the district reiterated its stance on maintaining a safe environment but urged the community to avoid being swayed by “inaccurate and often anonymous claims.”

One of the athletes involved has since transferred to another district, while the other two athletes have decided not to participate in basketball this season, citing concerns for their well-being.