The Inter-Valley Conference released its all-conference selections for the 2021 high school football season.
Garaway boasted both the IVC South Player and Coach of the Year, in junior Jarrett Wallick and head coach Jason Wallick. The Pirates went 10-0 for the regular season and won the South with a 19-14 Week 10 win over then-undefeated Ridgewood.
The IVC North had two Players of the Year: seniors Chase Vacco (East Canton) and Noah Ball (Malvern).
Malvern head coach Matt Chiurco earned the North’s Coach of the Year honors for taking the Hornets to an 8-2 record (5-0 in IVC North).
Malvern and Garaway led all IVC schools with six first-team selections apiece (ten overall), while Buckeye Trail, East Canton, Indian Valley, and Ridgewood each had five first-teamers.
The following lists the all-conference selections for the IVC North and South Divisions:
IVC NORTH FIRST TEAM
| Dakota Milliken | Buckeye Trail | Sr |
| Nick Neuhart | Buckeye Trail | Jr |
| Franko Rome | Buckeye Trail | Sr |
| Shane Smith | Buckeye Trail | Sr |
| Aiden Snodgrass | Buckeye Trail | Sr |
| Jake McCullough | East Canton | Jr |
| Grayden Clark | East Canton | Sr |
| Austin Jones | East Canton | Sr |
| Chase Vacco | East Canton | Sr |
| Branson Wolf | East Canton | Sr |
| Noah Ball | Malvern | Sr |
| Sam Foster | Malvern | Sr |
| Tristan Phillips | Malvern | Sr |
| Johnny Walker | Malvern | Sr |
| Xavier Watson | Malvern | Jr |
| Bryson White | Malvern | Sr |
| Corbin Ebersbach | Newcomerstown | Sr |
| Gatlin Fish | Newcomerstown | Sr |
| Trenton Newkirk | Newcomerstown | Sr |
| Lucas Lindsay | Strasburg | Sr |
| Matt Cox | Strasburg | So |
| James Brooks | Tuscarawas Central Catholic | Sr |
| Jordan Cherry | Tuscarawas Central Catholic | Jr |
| Gavin Douglass | Tuscarawas Central Catholic | So |
| Thayne Mahaffey | Tuscarawas Central Catholic | Jr |
IVC SOUTH, FIRST TEAM
| Mac McCluskey | Claymont | Jr |
| Mason Mehok | Claymont | Sr |
| Brody Rauch | Claymont | Sr |
| Brayden Adams | Garaway | Sr |
| Ethan Miller | Garaway | Jr |
| Sam Page | Garaway | Sr |
| Brady Roden | Garaway | Jr |
| Jarett Wallick | Garaway | Jr |
| Logan Yoder | Garaway | Jr |
| Kale Kochman | Indian Valley | Jr |
| Cole Lancaster | Indian Valley | Sr |
| Trevor Myers | Indian Valley | Sr |
| Kolton Thomas | Indian Valley | So |
| Samuel Zurcher | Indian Valley | Jr |
| Kadin Bradford | Ridgewood | Sr |
| Xavier Lamneck | Ridgewood | Sr |
| Kigenn Millender | Ridgewood | Sr |
| Dalton Patterson | Ridgewood | Sr |
| Gabe Tingle | Ridgewood | Sr |
| Kanyon McCort | Sandy Valley | Sr |
| Wyatt Moyer | Sandy Valley | Sr |
| Ben Petro | Sandy Valley | Sr |
| Mason Tucci | Sandy Valley | Sr |
| Drew Congdon | Tusky Valley | Jr |
| Beau Wolf | Tusky Valley | Jr |
IVC NORTH, SECOND TEAM
Donovan Geiger Buckeye Trail So
Landon Koch Buckeye Trail Jr
Charlie Parry Buckeye Trail So
Alexander Campbell East Canton Jr
Toby Schrader East Canton Jr
Mario Snellenberger East Canton Sr
Kaden Grinder Malvern Sr
Trevor Slider Malvern Sr
K. J. Thomas Malvern Sr
David Newkirk Newcomerstown Jr
Bunk Millender Newcomerstown Fr
Brandon Weber Newcomerstown Jr
Derek Rissler Strasburg So
Kaden Smith Strasburg Jr
Jacob Ross Strasburg Sr
Zane Douglass Tuscarawas Central Catholic Sr
Jacob Renicker Tuscarawas Central Catholic Sr
Hunter Sabin Tuscarawas Central Catholic Sr
IVC SOUTH, SECOND TEAM
Greg Bradshaw Claymont Sr
Cole McCabe Claymont Jr
Cooper Nalley Claymont Sr
Alexander Roden Garaway Jr
Ty Winters Garaway Jr
JD Young Garaway Sr
Gavin Henry Indian Valley Jr
Remmington Myers Indian Valley Jr
Joe Reynolds Indian Valley Sr
Kolby Masloski Ridgewood Sr
Alex Stroup Ridgewood Sr
Zander Stroup Ridgewood Sr
Chad Davis Sandy Valley So
Jared Drobney Sandy Valley Sr
Andrew Neary Sandy Valley So
Cole Clements Tusky Valley So
Brad Lab Tusky Valley Jr
Logan Postlewait Tusky Valley Jr
IVC NORTH, HONORABLE MENTION
Buckeye Trail: Brady Hastings, So
East Canton: Nathan Cilona, Sr
Malvern: Will Steinberg, Sr
Newcomerstown: Spencer Ebersbach, Fr
Strasburg: Drake Reifenschneider, So
TCC: Casey Green, So
IVC SOUTH, HONORABLE MENTION
Claymont: Luke Porco, Sr
Garaway: Payton Keller, So
Indian Valley: Caleb Wells, Sr
Ridgewood: Kauelen Smith, Jr
Sandy Valley: Troy Snyder, Soph
Tusky Valley: Ben Brideweser, Jr